Top marks in English fail to spell proficiency
Sarah Michael
December 15, 2010Until my first year of university last year, when one of my tutors quite bluntly pointed it out to me, I had always written ''definately'' instead of ''definitely''.
I went through 12 years of schooling and completed both Advanced and Extension 1 English during my HSC in 2007 without knowing how to spell the word. I was also still unclear about the difference between ''its'' and ''it's''. And I had no idea when it was appropriate to use a semicolon (I still have to Google ''semicolons'' to remind myself).
Many people my age have an appalling grasp of spelling and grammar. Some blame instant messaging and the wide use of abbreviations. Others blame the (arguably) apathetic members of Generation Y. I blame the high school English curriculum.
The NSW Board of Studies years 7-10 English syllabus aims to teach students to ''speak, listen, read, write, view and represent'' and ''use language and communicate appropriately and effectively''. Punctuation, spelling and grammar are itemised in the curriculum, but there seems to be a lack of focus on spelling and grammar in the classroom.
And what message does it send in HSC English exams, when students are not marked down for spelling or punctuation errors? Bad spelling and punctuation only count against them when the marker cannot understand what it is they are trying to express.
One English teacher told me: ''I think they just assume teachers will just put [spelling and grammar] into their program when they do their own individual programming in the school. But the issue there is that the syllabus itself is so full of all this other stuff that they are requiring us to teach kids, that there isn't much time left when I'll only see one class five times every two weeks.''
Personally, I have vague memories of learning the definitions of nouns, adjectives, pronouns and prepositions in primary school, which I remember to this day. I also remember doing a weekly spelling test. But high school English was different. I learnt how to spot a simile and metaphor from a mile away. I learnt to be critical of the books I read and the films I watched. I learnt to question why an author or a filmmaker would phrase something a certain way or use a certain type of camera shot. What I did not learn about was spelling or grammar.
If I made a mistake, my teacher would circle it in red pen. Sometimes I caught myself wondering whether I should be using ''it's'' or ''its''. But, being a typical 15-year-old, instead of bothering to find out, I would go online and try to download another episode of The O.C. or something.
Many internet browsers have spellcheck functions but none seem able to check grammar. This is odd, considering the amazing advancements in technology over the past decade.
Perhaps it is because a computer program cannot pick up on the context of a sentence and tell whether a person means ''it's'' or ''its''. Computer spell checks have made people lazy when typing.
Logging on to Facebook is a quick way to discover how far-reaching the problem is. The majority of my 400 or so friends would be between 16 to 25, making my news feed the perfect place to survey the grammatical know-how of Generation Y. And for the most part it is pretty grim.
I am not talking about people writing all in lower case. But in more than half the posts, I see people mix up ''their'', ''there'' and ''they're''. They confuse ''your'' and ''you're''. And, of course, ''it's'' and ''its'' are highly interchangeable.
Not all Facebook users are grammarless fools. There is a community of vigilant social networkers who take their spelling and punctuation very seriously, creating Facebook groups such as '' 'Let's eat Grandma' or 'Let's eat, Grandma' - Punctuation saves lives'' ' and ''You use 'your' and 'you're' properly? Excuse me while I undress myself''. Both have more than 191,000 members.
The draft years 7-10 Australian Curriculum for English on the Australian Curriculum Assessment and Reporting Authority website includes a specific focus on spelling and grammar. Let's hope this means that the next generation will finish school knowing how to construct a proper sentence.
Spelling and grammar remain important because one error can completely distort the meaning of what we are trying to say. Just ask grandma.
Sarah Michael is a third-year journalism student at UTS.
I went through 12 years of schooling and completed both Advanced and Extension 1 English during my HSC in 2007 without knowing how to spell the word. I was also still unclear about the difference between ''its'' and ''it's''. And I had no idea when it was appropriate to use a semicolon (I still have to Google ''semicolons'' to remind myself).
Many people my age have an appalling grasp of spelling and grammar. Some blame instant messaging and the wide use of abbreviations. Others blame the (arguably) apathetic members of Generation Y. I blame the high school English curriculum.
The NSW Board of Studies years 7-10 English syllabus aims to teach students to ''speak, listen, read, write, view and represent'' and ''use language and communicate appropriately and effectively''. Punctuation, spelling and grammar are itemised in the curriculum, but there seems to be a lack of focus on spelling and grammar in the classroom.
And what message does it send in HSC English exams, when students are not marked down for spelling or punctuation errors? Bad spelling and punctuation only count against them when the marker cannot understand what it is they are trying to express.
One English teacher told me: ''I think they just assume teachers will just put [spelling and grammar] into their program when they do their own individual programming in the school. But the issue there is that the syllabus itself is so full of all this other stuff that they are requiring us to teach kids, that there isn't much time left when I'll only see one class five times every two weeks.''
Personally, I have vague memories of learning the definitions of nouns, adjectives, pronouns and prepositions in primary school, which I remember to this day. I also remember doing a weekly spelling test. But high school English was different. I learnt how to spot a simile and metaphor from a mile away. I learnt to be critical of the books I read and the films I watched. I learnt to question why an author or a filmmaker would phrase something a certain way or use a certain type of camera shot. What I did not learn about was spelling or grammar.
If I made a mistake, my teacher would circle it in red pen. Sometimes I caught myself wondering whether I should be using ''it's'' or ''its''. But, being a typical 15-year-old, instead of bothering to find out, I would go online and try to download another episode of The O.C. or something.
Many internet browsers have spellcheck functions but none seem able to check grammar. This is odd, considering the amazing advancements in technology over the past decade.
Perhaps it is because a computer program cannot pick up on the context of a sentence and tell whether a person means ''it's'' or ''its''. Computer spell checks have made people lazy when typing.
Logging on to Facebook is a quick way to discover how far-reaching the problem is. The majority of my 400 or so friends would be between 16 to 25, making my news feed the perfect place to survey the grammatical know-how of Generation Y. And for the most part it is pretty grim.
I am not talking about people writing all in lower case. But in more than half the posts, I see people mix up ''their'', ''there'' and ''they're''. They confuse ''your'' and ''you're''. And, of course, ''it's'' and ''its'' are highly interchangeable.
Not all Facebook users are grammarless fools. There is a community of vigilant social networkers who take their spelling and punctuation very seriously, creating Facebook groups such as '' 'Let's eat Grandma' or 'Let's eat, Grandma' - Punctuation saves lives'' ' and ''You use 'your' and 'you're' properly? Excuse me while I undress myself''. Both have more than 191,000 members.
The draft years 7-10 Australian Curriculum for English on the Australian Curriculum Assessment and Reporting Authority website includes a specific focus on spelling and grammar. Let's hope this means that the next generation will finish school knowing how to construct a proper sentence.
Spelling and grammar remain important because one error can completely distort the meaning of what we are trying to say. Just ask grandma.
Sarah Michael is a third-year journalism student at UTS.
Source: http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/society-and-culture/top-marks-in-english-fail-to-spell-proficiency-20101214-18wq7.html
No comments:
Post a Comment